CRT

Clema Research Team

Research

The Clema research team publishes original analysis and practical guides for institutional research and institutional effectiveness professionals.

Articles by Clema Research Team

Federal data

What is a CIP code? The federal taxonomy behind every program number in higher ed

A plain-English explainer of CIP codes: the two, four, and six digit structure, who maintains it, the 2020 revision, and every federal system that hangs off it.

Aug 30, 20267 mins read
Federal data

The Enrollment Cliff by State: Where the Freshman Supply Is Already Falling

First-time freshmen by state of residence, 2016–2024: New York is down 15,700, Pennsylvania down 13,100, Alaska down a quarter. With in-state reliance for every state, a full exposure ranking.

Aug 29, 202610 mins read
Running an IR office

How to Say No to Data Requests Without Burning Bridges

A practical framework for IR teams drowning in ad hoc requests: a five-criteria scoring rubric, word-for-word scripts for saying no to deans, faculty, and cabinets, and what to say yes to instead.

Aug 30, 20267 mins read
Choosing IR tools

Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Higher Ed Data, Explained for IR Offices

A plain-English RAG explainer for institutional research: how retrieval-augmented generation works on campus data, why it fits IR work, where it fails, and the questions to ask any vendor.

Aug 31, 20268 mins read
Federal data

A third of colleges cut a team, and the team was small for years first

Institution-level EADA analysis of the decade to AY 2024-25. 32.01 percent of continuously filing colleges cut a team, 261 of those cutters ended the decade flat or larger, tennis and golf supplied 40.5 percent of every drop, and the teams that disappear are small for years first. Two null results on Title IX, and the variable that actually predicts cutting.

Aug 28, 202612 mins read
Federal data

One college sport is vanishing, and the fastest-growing one has no name

On a balanced panel of 1,910 EADA filers, tennis is the only large sport in real decline: minus 97 institutions in ten years and minus 124 in twenty. Softball, golf, football and basketball all look like losers in the raw comparison and all four are positive once the institution set is held fixed. Meanwhile Other Sports went from 60 institutions to 432.

Aug 28, 202611 mins read
Federal data

55 percent of the students, 42 percent of the athletes: the Title IX proportionality gap, measured

Women are 55.15 percent of undergraduates and 42.10 percent of athletic participants at the 2,037 institutions that filed EADA for AY 2024-25, a 13.05 point gap. It is wider than in 2014-15, football explains roughly half of it, and the 1,161 colleges that sponsor no football at all still carry 10.59 points.

Aug 28, 202612 mins read
Federal data

Athletics revenue is not revenue: 40,829 EADA filings, zero deficits

Across 40,829 institution-year records from AY 2005-06 through AY 2024-25, EADA contains zero reported athletics deficits. In AY 2024-25, 1,288 of 2,037 institutions report revenue exactly equal to expense, to the dollar. What that means for the question your provost actually asked.

Aug 28, 202613 mins read
Federal data

95,584 fewer clerical jobs, 80,571 more in finance: IPEDS staffing by occupation on 4,902 colleges, 2012 to 2024

On a fixed panel of 4,902 colleges, office and administrative support fell from 13.95 to 10.10 percent of all staff between 2012 and 2024, a loss of 95,584 positions, while business and financial operations grew 43.7 percent. The full occupational breakout, plus the honest answer about where IR staff sit in IPEDS.

Aug 27, 202614 mins read
Federal data

Graduates per opening: matching IPEDS completions against BLS demand across 17 CIP to SOC pairs

IPEDS 2024-25 completions divided by BLS 2024-34 annual openings for 17 CIP to SOC pairs, sixteen of them credential gated. Nursing 1.39, paralegal 0.25, 12 of 17 below 1.00, plus the state rankings and every reason to distrust them.

Aug 26, 202614 mins read
Federal accountability

Why your program has no earnings number: 76.2 percent of PPD:2026 is dark, and what to put in the memo instead

In PPD:2026, 159,461 of 209,321 programs have no published median earnings figure, and the same 159,461 rows carry no federal earnings-test determination. Here is the decision tree for why a cell is blank, the floors we could observe in the file, and how much a second source recovers.

Aug 25, 202616 mins read
Federal data

Programs die small: which programs colleges are quietly closing, and which fields churn fastest

3,804 of 109,790 IPEDS programs went dark after the 2022-23 award year, a 3.46 percent rate that has not moved in nine years. 76.7 percent of them awarded three or fewer credentials in their final year, the fields that churn fastest are mostly the ones adding programs at the same time, and field-level closure rates do not line up with the federal earnings test.

Aug 22, 202614 mins read
Federal accountability

Same 3,361 programs, old GE test vs new OBBBA test: 569 walk free and 19 get caught

On the 3,361 GE programs in PPD:2026 where both regimes can be scored, 1,002 fail both, 569 fail only the old GE test and 19 fail only the new OBBBA test. The two casualty lists overlap on 63.0 percent of their combined 1,590 programs.

Aug 21, 202613 mins read
Federal data

Completion gaps by field: the higher a bachelor's field pays, the smaller the women's share of its graduates

Sort 124 bachelor's fields by graduate earnings and the women's share of completions falls from 75.7% to 44.8%. Take nursing out of the top group and it drops to 27.0%. The field-level baseline IR teams can benchmark a program against.

Aug 20, 202614 mins read
Federal data

Computing up 56.9 percent, nursing flat: bachelor's degree production by field, 2018-19 to 2024-25

Bachelor-level registered nursing produced 154,489 graduates in 2018-19 and 154,529 in 2024-25, a net change of 40 awards, while 113 more institutions reported a BSN program. Computing added 50,966. The full field-by-field breakout from IPEDS Completions.

Aug 19, 202613 mins read
Federal accountability

1,220 programs fail the OBBBA earnings test in PPD:2026. Here is the field and credential breakdown.

We ran the official OBBBA earnings test across all 209,321 rows of PPD:2026. 1,220 programs fail, out of 44,052 actually tested, a 2.77 percent rate. Visual and Performing Arts carries 27.7 percent of the failures, associate degrees fail at 6.60 percent, and 455 programs miss by less than $2,000.

Aug 18, 202613 mins read
Using Clema

Clema News and Updates: What's New for IR and IE Teams

A general news and updates index for Clema covering product launches, whitepapers, IR benchmark releases, conference appearances, and company news relevant to IR and IE teams in higher ed.

Jul 7, 20264 mins read
Career and community

IR Resources and Further Reading: Everything We Published in One Place

A single hub of every Clema guide, research paper, IR benchmark, conference list, podcast, book, and definitional framework the IR team should bookmark. Updated as new pieces ship.

Jul 7, 20263 mins read
Running an IR office

The IR Team's Year: When Each Season Hits and What to Prepare

A when/lifecycle guide for IR teams: which months are peak, moderate, and low for ad-hoc requests, what reports and accreditations hit each season, and what to prepare ahead of time.

Jul 7, 20266 mins read
Using Clema

How a Large IR Team Uses Clema to Manage Breadth Across Schools

How a large IR team (8+ staff) uses Clema's analytics, peer benchmarking, and predictive analytics to scale analyses across schools instead of pulling data one school at a time.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Data definitions

How an IR Office Uses Clema When Their Key Analyst Resigns

How an IR office uses Clema's data platform to preserve definitions, sources, and terminology across a key-person departure, anchored in the 85% key-person dependency finding.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Data definitions

How an IR Director Uses Clema When "Retention" Means Five Different Things

How an IR director uses Clema to surface the cohort definition on every answer, so "retention" stops meaning whatever the requester had in mind.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Using Clema

How an IE Director Uses Clema to Bridge the Dashboard-vs-Email Gap

How an IE director uses Clema to keep stakeholders out of the email queue and let them ask dashboards in plain English, anchored in the whitepaper finding on dashboard adoption.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Using Clema

How an Office of One Uses Clema During IPEDS Peak Season

How a one-person IR office uses Clema to handle IPEDS pulls and ad-hoc dean requests in parallel during peak season, when capacity utilization hits 90%.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Running an IR office

IR Capacity Benchmarks: The Real Cost of Ad Hoc Data Requests

Quantified IR capacity benchmarks from 50+ interviews: 40 to 60% of team capacity consumed by ad hoc requests, 2 to 5 clarification cycles per request, and 220 to 3,200 hours annually reclaimable. By team size.

Jul 7, 20267 mins read
Choosing IR tools

What Clema Cannot Do Yet (and When It Is Not the Right Fit)

Where Clema does not fit today: very small institutions, institutions with no data source to connect, real-time pipeline needs, and bespoke statistical research. Honesty content for IR buyers.

Jul 7, 20266 mins read
Using Clema

How to Ask an IPEDS Question in Clema

A procedural guide for asking IPEDS questions in Clema: the prompt structure, the cohort and year disambiguation, the source check, and four worked examples.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Using Clema

How to Build a Peer Group in Clema

A procedural guide for building a peer group in Clema by Carnegie class, control, region, or designation, and pulling the same metric for each peer in one conversation.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Using Clema

How to Set Up SSO With Clema (SAML and OAuth)

A procedural walkthrough for configuring SSO with Clema using SAML 2.0 or OAuth 2.0, including metadata exchange, attribute mapping, MFA, and the test login that confirms it works.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Using Clema

Clema Onboarding: A Four-Week Setup Checklist

A week-by-week onboarding checklist for Clema: who does what, what gets signed, what gets connected, and what success looks like at each phase over 2 to 4 weeks.

Jul 7, 20266 mins read
Using Clema

Get Started With IPEDS in Plain English

A quick start for querying IPEDS in plain English with Clema: enrollment, graduation rates, peer comparison, finance, and faculty figures, with the federal source on every answer.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Using Clema

First Five Questions to Ask Clema

Five plain-English questions to ask Clema in the first session, what each one demonstrates, and how to interpret the sourced answer.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Choosing IR tools

Clema vs HelioCampus: A Cost Comparison for IR Teams

A side-by-side cost comparison of Clema and HelioCampus Theia Analyst for IR and IE teams, covering published pricing, implementation, and what is included.

Jul 7, 20266 mins read
Choosing IR tools

Clema vs EAB Edify: A Cost Comparison for IR Teams

A side-by-side cost comparison of Clema and EAB Edify for IR and IE teams, covering published pricing, implementation fees, and what is included at each tier.

Jul 7, 20266 mins read
Choosing IR tools

Why Higher Ed Needs Its Own AI Assistant, Not ChatGPT

Why general-purpose AI assistants fail on higher-ed data questions and what a higher-ed-native AI like Clema gets right: domain knowledge, real data, and sourced answers.

Jul 7, 20265 mins read
Running an IR office

Why IR Capacity Has Not Kept Up With Data Demand

The structural mismatch between rising IR data request volume and flat team capacity, and why conversational AI is now the only path that scales without a hiring cycle.

Jul 7, 20266 mins read
Federal data

A Calendar of Federal Data Releases Higher Ed IR Teams Should Track in 2026

A practical release calendar for the 12 federal datasets IR and IE teams depend on: IPEDS, College Scorecard, Pell, loans, cohort default rates, Clery, EADA, PSEO, PPD, DAPIP, and BLS OEWS.

Jul 6, 202611 mins read
Data definitions

Why 'enrolled student' has five definitions

In a study of 20 IR and IE offices, one term routinely carried several valid definitions at once. Here is why that happens, the eight layers it happens at, and why it breaks reporting even when the data is clean.

Jun 26, 202611 mins read
Data definitions

Is your institutional knowledge one resignation away from gone?

A diagnostic for institutional research teams: the Institutional Intelligence Gap, the three tiers (55% Large, 40% Moderate, 5% Small), a five-factor self-assessment, and an illustrative cost model for key-person dependency in higher ed.

Jun 26, 202612 mins read
Data definitions

From person-dependent to system-supported: a framework for governing data definitions

Creating data definitions is achievable. Maintenance is where most efforts collapse. Here is a six-step framework, an AI-readiness argument, and tier-by-tier next steps for IR/IE teams.

Jun 26, 202612 mins read
Career and community

How to learn institutional research: certificates, courses, and free training

A directory of 25 ways to learn institutional research: graduate certificates, AIR professional development, free IPEDS and PDP training, executive programs, and self-paced courses, with formats, costs, and links.

Jun 25, 202612 mins read
Predictive analytics

From reactive reporting to proactive prediction: a playbook for IR teams

IR teams already sit on years of attendance, GPA, LMS, and aid data. A practical guide to turning that record into forward-looking predictions that change what advisors, deans, and provosts can do this term.

Jun 5, 202610 mins read
Predictive analytics

Why gradient boosting beats LLMs for student retention prediction

A plain-English guide for IR leadership on why classical ML (specifically XGBoost) outperforms LLMs on student-level retention and graduation prediction, what the benchmark literature actually shows, and how to read a per-student risk score.

Jun 5, 202611 mins read
Predictive analytics

Predictive analytics in higher ed: the $40-a-month stack vs the $200K platform

A straight comparison between the open-source predictive-analytics stack ($40 to $95 per month) and the major incumbent platforms ($30K to $200K per year). Covers infrastructure cost, licensing, where incumbents are strong and where they leave gaps, and a build-vs-buy framework.

Jun 5, 202610 mins read
Predictive analytics

Predicting term-to-term retention: what a working model actually looks at

A practical look at the features, engineering choices, and timing decisions that drive a real term-to-term retention model. Written for IR leadership who want to understand what the model sees before they hand its output to advisors.

Jun 5, 202611 mins read
Predictive analytics

Predicting graduation within 150% time: course combinations, confidence, and committee-ready explanations

The graduation use case in detail. Features, course-combination effects, plain-English metric reading, the small-group floor that prevents false certainty, and the drift management every long-horizon prediction needs.

Jun 5, 202611 mins read
Predictive analytics

Forecasting enrollment and program viability: where prediction meets cabinet-level decisions

A practical guide to the predictive questions Provosts and CFOs own. Enrollment forecasting (ARIMA, Prophet, LSTM), yield prediction, program margin and viability, IPEDS-based screening, and the honest limits of each.

Jun 5, 202610 mins read
Federal accountability

Six files, 209,321 programs, three join keys: turning PPD:2026 into answers your provost actually asks

PPD:2026 looks like a single dataset. On disk it's six Excel files joined on opeid6 + credlev + cip4, with mixed-vintage dollars, statistical-noise privacy suppression, and a CIP-4 key that doesn't match the CIP-6 the STATS test will use. Here's where the analyst hours actually go, and how to skip them.

Jun 2, 202610 mins read
Running an IR office

Is Your University's Data Request Form Actually Optimized? How Better Design Can Reduce 77% of Clarification Time

35% of universities have no formal intake process, and 77% of IR offices require extensive clarification before analysis begins. Analysis of 18 university data request forms reveals what the best systems do differently.

Feb 25, 20268 mins read
Federal data

Who's Growing Through Dual Enrollment? A Side-by-Side Benchmark of Community Colleges and Four-Year Institutions

IPEDS 2023–2024 data reveals four-year institutions growing 3x faster in dual enrollment than community colleges, while community colleges carry 32.4% structural reliance. A full side-by-side benchmark.

Feb 25, 20268 mins read
Running an IR office

What IR Teams Really Benchmark: Evidence from 50 Interviews

Discover what IR teams actually benchmark most often, from student outcomes and faculty metrics to aspirational peer lists, based on evidence from 50 institutional research interviews.

Feb 25, 202610 mins read
Running an IR office

What Is the Relationship Between Data Request Intake Quality, Request Intelligence, and Workload in Institutional Research Given That 78% of Requests Require 10+ Follow-Up Questions?

Research shows 80% of IR data requests arrive missing critical elements. Learn how Request Intelligence (the quality of requests at intake) determines whether your team spends time analyzing or clarifying.

Feb 12, 202610 mins read
Running an IR office

Best Practices for Institutional Researchers to Optimize Data Requests and Reclaim the 60% of Team's Capacity

Discover proven strategies from IR leaders to streamline data requests, implement self-service dashboards effectively, and reclaim up to 60% of your team's capacity for strategic work.

Jan 12, 202612 mins read